In the late summer of 2020, a friend told me that a regional magazine was seeking submissions. Three weeks later, I submitted the story below. The publication accepted it but would serialize it due to its length. I’m pretty confident the publication went belly-up before publishing the entire piece. I base this assumption on the fact that they ghosted me suddenly after the first issue.
Overall, I think “The Townies” is a good story – or at least a good idea for a story – and I am satisfied with the work I put into it. I have complaints: the balance between explanation and ambiguity favors the latter. The ending is unsatisfying, and the cross-cutting between sections is rough. But these are minor issues. Someday, I might come back to this idea and see if one more draft can sand it down to perfection. But not today.
***
The Townies
I grumbled, then answered, “I told you I don’t know anything.”
The detective exhaled smoke and placed his cigarette on his ashtray. He leaned in, looked me in the eyes, and said, “I find that hard to believe, James.”
This wasn’t my opening round in the station’s metal-gray interrogation room. Its official name was the “Police Information Room,” but it was an interrogation room out of an old film noir. Neither was this the first time Detective Price of the State Police questioned me. I was the first of the local teens he interviewed when he arrived in town. He must’ve cycled through the rest of the bunch and come no closer to solving the mystery.
I sighed, “Why? I’m a normal fucking kid.”
Detective Price shook his head, “You’re not normal. You’re a Select-men’s kid in a town where they’re all turning up dead.”
“What’s so mysterious about those deaths? I thought they were both suicides.”
“That was the official ruling.”
—
NEWSCASTER: We now take you to Angela Adams in Catamount. Angela?
ANGELA ADAMS: Thanks, Bobbie. I’m standing in front of Catamount Town Hall, where a large press conference was held this morning.
(Earlier that day.)
MEDICAL EXAMINER: As I listed in the reports, I have concluded both deaths were suicides. If the state disagrees, it has a right to investigate, and I intend to cooperate with that process.
ANGELA ADAMS: That was local medical examiner James Perez. He’s involved in the controversy rocking this quiet Berkshire community. He has ruled the two deaths of selectmen’s children as “suicides,” but the State Police disagree.
(Earlier that week.)
UNIFORMED SPOKESWOMAN: We have decided to open up our own investigation. The attention given to deaths of this nature has been inadequate.
ANGELA ADAMS: The state’s decision has put this quiet Western Mass town on edge.
—
I perked up, “So you think someone murdered them?”
The detective gave me a look, “I thought I was the one asking questions here.”
Detective Price adjusted his suspenders. He was the first man I ever saw in person who wore suspenders. I’d seen suspenders before, but the men wearing them were all guys in old black-and-white films. I didn’t even know clothing companies still made pants with suspenders. Detective Price pulled a file from his messenger bag and placed it on the table. He looked up at me while he opened it and asked, “But don’t you think it’s strange how two teens have killed themselves? And in a town that didn’t have a single suicide at all last year?”
I looked down at the file. Inside it were photos from the area where Libby had killed herself. I could still remember the brown-red stain on the monument left by her body’s fluids. I saw it before they put the tarp over it.
“I’m going to be sick.”
“Me too, kid.”
—
LIBBY G. MORRISON, age 17, died on Monday, February 1st, 2010, in her hometown of Catamount. From her birth on March 1st, 1992, to her death, she nourished people with love, faith, and music. She was born in Catamount to David and Britt Morrison (née Johnson) and was an only child. Libby started playing the piano at five, and by 15, she was giving lessons from the parlor of her house. She was planning to attend a performing arts school for college to complete her training. From there, Libby hoped to start a career teaching children how to play the instrument. She was also a faithful Christian. She served the Catamount Congregational Church as a service pianist. Left to honor Libby’s memory are her parents, her friends, and the Catamount community. People will remember her as a bright, shining light in the town she loved and the church she served. Funeral services will be on Thursday at 11:00 AM at Catamount Congregational Church. The Rev. Jodie Howard will preside. All are welcome to attend.
—
I rested my head on the metal table. The room’s fluorescent lighting was making my headache worse. “Then why are you looking at the pictures?”
“Because this ‘suicide’ doesn’t make any sense. I’ve never heard of anybody killing themselves via impalement. Have you?”
I chuckled, and the vibrations shook the table a little. “You’re the expert, not me.”
I heard Detective Price flip the file shut. “Yeah, but you live in this strange little town.”
I exhaled, bringing my head up to look at the cop. “That doesn’t make me an expert on the place.”
“It means you know a bit more than I do. I have some questions about this town.”
“Ask away. It’s not like I can leave.”
Detective Price opened up another file. I could tell by looking at it that the papers inside were copies of various town documents. Some of them looked old enough to date from the town’s founding. “Why are all the selectmen fathers to only one child each?”
—
Catamount, Massachusetts
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
Catamount is a town in Franklin County, Massachusetts. In 1812, the Catamount schoolhouse was the first to raise the United States flag. Catamount was a farming community until the late 19th century. Nearby Pocumtuck Mountain was often a popular destination for people around the state. In 1880, Governor John Long visited the Old Home Days festival on Pocumtuck Mountain.
Due partly to the remote location, Catamount was only a tiny village until the early 20th century. The discovery of a “medicinal hot spring” resulted in an influx of wealthy Bostonians. These Boston Brahman families displaced the local farmers. The Commonwealth incorporated most of the surrounding villages into Catamount in 1967. The summer tourism industry dominates Catamount’s economy. The town-owned Pocumtuck Mountain Resort funds the town’s municipal budget.
—
I shrugged my shoulders. “I guess they all won the genetic lottery.”
Detective Price lit a cigarette. He inhaled a noxious amount of smoke, then held the cigarette and watched it burn while exhaling. “If you all are offing yourselves, I wouldn’t call that ‘winning the genetic lottery.’”
I looked at the one-way mirror behind Detective Price. Was it hiding somebody scrutinizing me for any signs of guilt? “Why am I still here? How much longer do you plan on keeping me here?”
Detective Price put his cigarette out in the ashtray. “Not much longer. You’re not under arrest or even a suspect. Consider this a fact-finding mission.”
“I’m sure you could get more out of the town’s historical society than me.”
“Members of the town’s historical society aren’t killing themselves in Catamount. Selectmen’s kids are. There were four of you when the year started; now there’s only two.”
“Look, Detective Price, I got nothing more to give you. Let me go home.”
—
r/Ask an American
What was the creepiest town or state you’ve been to, and why?
[ASlickbackNamedPimp] 18 points – 11 years ago
Catamount, Massachusetts, is on the border between Massachusetts and Vermont. It feels like the whole town is some sort of living museum or dead. It’s dominated by this big mountain (for Massachusetts, anyway), and the entire city rests on the slope. The place looks like it could topple over at any moment. It reminded me of that fake town we dropped a nuke on in the ’50s, a terrifying artificial feeling all around.
[JesusElPacifico] 4 points – 11 years ago
My family goes deer hunting in the area. In the last few years, we’ve had to stop butchering our meat, so we go to one of the few remaining local farms. You pull up to a beautiful farm, and a handful of dogs come running up with toys in their mouths. Wait, those aren’t toys. They’re deer heads. The dogs lick you with blood-covered faces. There are deer heads and feet everywhere. And then you meet the people.
—
“Did you ever meet Mr. White, the town manager?”
I thought back for a second. “Dave? Of course, I did. He was a friend of my parents. He came to all our holiday parties and stuff.”
Detective Price perked up and asked, “So you’d say you were close with David?”
“I wouldn’t say I was close to him. But he was a family friend, and when I was younger, I’d call him Uncle Dave.”
“Did that make your ‘real’ uncles jealous?”
“I don’t have any uncles. Or aunts. Both my parents are only children. I told you that the last time you brought me in for questioning.”
Detective Price smiled. “I must’ve forgotten. Isn’t it weird that all the selectmen – and their wives – are only children, like all their kids?”
“I never gave it much thought, to be honest. Yeah, that is kinda weird.”
“What do you think about, James?”
“The stuff every boy my age thinks about. I think about video games the most. I’m good at League of Legends.”
“I don’t know or care to know about that.”
—
On Saturday, January 16th, 2010, DAVID WHITE, a loving husband, passed away at age 75. David was born in Boston, Massachusetts, on April 30th, 1934, to Charles and Alice (née Stanton) White. He received his law degree from Harvard University in 1961. David practiced business law for 13 years in Springfield. On March 28th, 1975, he married Karen (née Cole) Winter. Later that year, Catamount appointed him Town Manager, a position he held until his death.
David had a passion for painting. He loved bird watching and combined his two favorite hobbies to create extraordinary art. His paintings of various birds were much admired, but not only by friends and family. They were also loved by customers of the Wisdom School coffee shop, which displayed them. He was also an avid lover of Celtic music. People will remember his quick wit, infectious smile, and compassionate spirit. Preceding David in death was his father, Charles, and his mother, Alice. Surviving him is his wife, Karen. Funeral services will be a private affair. Instead of flowers, send donations to the Catamount Historical Society.
—
After what felt like forever, Detective Price said the words I’d been waiting to hear. “Alright, you can go now.”
I bolted out of my chair, then tried to play it cool, adopting a casual demeanor as I walked by the detective. I had nothing to hide from him, yet I felt I had to model that fact to him. Then he grabbed my wrist on the way out and spoke to me. “Something about this case doesn’t make any sense. Stay safe out there, and if you come across anything odd or fucked up, you tell me right away. Got it?”
“I… think so, sir?”
“Good. Ms. Moore is waiting on the bench outside. Send her in on your way out.”
He relaxed his grip, and I got the fuck out of there. That trip lasted only a few steps because something was clearly wrong as soon as I exited the room. Sarah (“Ms. Moore”) wasn’t sitting on the bench, though her purse was. The lights were off, leaving only the natural lighting offered by the setting sun. I turned around to tell Detective Price. He was already standing behind me, an unlit cigarette dangling from his lips.
—
Third Selectmen Child Goes Missing in Catamount
by Kyle Peterson, Associated Press
Events in Catamount have again taken a disturbing turn. Sarah Moore, 16, only daughter of town Selectmen Erwin Moore, went missing yesterday. This follows the recent deaths of two other children, Libby G. Morrison and John Campbell, 17. Both were the only children of other Selectmen. What makes Sarah’s disappearance so shocking? She was last seen inside the Catamount Police Station. She was waiting to answer questions for the state probe into the deaths mentioned above.
CCTV cameras recorded her walking to a window across the hall from where she was sitting. She stands at the window for several minutes, conversing with an unseen figure. Moore then exits the police station, leaving a purse with her belongings. The mysterious circumstances have furthered speculation of a serial killer in Catamount. This theory contradicts the ruling of medical examiner Jamie Perez, 38. His official reports concluded both Morrison and Campbell committed suicide. The state has thrown out this ruling and is investigating possible foul play.
—
The cops sent me home after recording my eyewitness statement. I guess they decided I answered enough questions for one day. Besides, Detective Price was grilling me when Sarah went missing. That’s a pretty rock-solid alibi. My parents were silent for the whole car ride home. They seemed so exhausted, and I can’t blame them. This year was a perfect storm for them. After Uncle David died, the new Town Manager discovered he’d been cooking the town’s books, and we were bankrupt. Drug use was becoming a real problem; one of my teachers died of an overdose during the summer. And, of course, there were all their co-worker’s kids dying.
With Sarah missing, I was the last of those kids left safe and sound. After tonight, there would be no doubt that a killer was on the loose. Would I get taken out of town for my safety? Beyond that, my thoughts focused on Sarah. I wanted her to be okay, even though my gut told me she wasn’t. She had always been kind to me, though we weren’t friends. Who could steal somebody out of their own life’s story like that?
—
Detective Price Investigation Log, August 1st, 2010:
How the fuck does a 16-year-old girl get kidnapped out of a police station? Why didn’t the desk officer on duty stop her from leaving the building? He claims he was getting a cup of coffee and didn’t see her go. Bullshit! Something about these cops stinks to high heaven. I’ve dealt with some local yokels with badges before, but nothing like this. The town cops claim they “lost” the clothes Campbell was wearing when discovered. Finding the box took two staties five minutes once they got access to the evidence locker.
If the cops are corrupt, their medical examiner is even worse. I bet he didn’t examine the bodies before he filed that report. Those cuts on Campbell’s body weren’t caused by “scraping” against the tree he was hanging from. Somebody flogged that boy before hanging him. There’s a serial killer in Catamount. He has a specific victim pool—like an Agatha Christie villain—and he’s almost out of options. If I can nab the fucker before he kills James Butler or that Moore girl, I’ll finally make a name. I can leave Franklin County and get promoted to one of the major squads.
—
My neighborhood is quiet. No kids playing outside or old ladies walking around pumping those five-pound weights. Sometimes, I see a curtain flutter or a shadow pass by a window. But people feel exposed outside. They want to stay inside their castles, only venturing when necessary. I don’t know why they feel so safe inside their homes. Sarah was inside the police station, surrounded by men with guns, and she still got taken. What could my neighbors do to defend themselves that the cops can’t?
Besides, this killer isn’t targeting them. I’m his next target. Detective Price has posted two state policemen in an SUV outside my home for my protection. It’s better than nothing. I fucking hate cops. The local cops are some of the biggest fucking bullies in town. Everyone knows Officer Adams tried to kill my friend Karim for being black and gay. At least Karim got his parents to move out of this dump. Now he lives in a Mc Mansion in Westfield. Meanwhile, I’m sitting here in Catamount, waiting for some psycho to barge in and decapitate me.
—
Steam Chat Logs, August 3rd, 2010
> Karim”TheDream” is now online.
Karim”TheDream”: Hey now, how are you holding up? (6:40PM)
BooEye-Stealer: I’m fine. (6:54 PM)
Karim”TheDream”: You didn’t reply for 14 minutes, bro! My heart was in my throat. (6:55 PM)
BooEye-Stealer: Can’t believe it found any room there next to your boyfriend’s cock!!! (6:58 PM)
Karim”TheDream”: Fuck you, man, you know I’m the top. (6:59 PM)
>BooEye-Stealer is now playing Left4Dead2.
BooEye-Stealer: Man, the water from the faucet has been weird lately. (7:03 PM)
Karim”TheDream”: What are you talking about? It’s the same H2O, as always. (7:04 PM)
BooEye-Stealer: No, man, this water got black-and-green flakes in it. (7:06 PM)
Karim”TheDream”: Dude, what the fuck? (7:08 PM)
BooEye-Stealer: I know, right (7:09 PM)
Karim”TheDream”: Get out of Catamount, James. (7:11 PM)
>BooEye-Stealer is now offline.
BooEye-Stealer: Jesus Christ, Karim. They found her. They found Sarah in the water tower. (1:32 AM)
—
I was there when they pulled Sarah’s body out of the water tower. A crowd had gathered at the scene overnight. One of the local cops blabbed about it to his wife, and she posted the news on Facebook. News used to travel fast in Catamount; now, it instantly reaches everywhere. None of us saw the body leave. The state police took it by helicopter to Bay-side Medical Center in Springfield. The state has so little faith in our local investigators that none of them touched the body.
While there, I saw my Dad talking with Sarah’s parents. They were off from the leading group of gawkers, so I couldn’t hear what they said to each other. Sarah’s parents seemed like they were in shock. Their faces were blank, and what I could hear was their voices, which were droning and monotone. I decided to walk over to them and offer my condolences. I didn’t know them well, but it was the least I could do. While walking over, I picked up the last thing Dad said before they all turned to look at me. With his hand clasped around Mr. Moore’s shoulder, Dad said, “At least it’ll be over soon.”
—
NEWSCASTER: We take you to Angela Adams in Catamount, where tragedy continues. Angela?
DETECTIVE PRICE: Yes, at this point, this is a murder investigation.
ANGELA ADAMS: Earlier today, Detective Christopher Price announced the discovery of Sarah Moore’s body. Moore, 16, had been missing for 21 days, prompting a massive county-wide search.
LOCAL RESIDENT: I’ve never seen anything like this happen in our little town.
LOCAL RESIDENT #2: People used to move to Catamount from Boston and other cities to escape crime. But after this, I can’t see anybody else coming here.
LOCAL RESIDENT #3: It’s all so bizarre. Why is this happening to us?
ANGELA ADAMS: Much of the attention is now on James Butler, the last Selectmen child. The boy is now under 24/7 police protection, but will this stop the serial killer from striking again?
—
It was a Department of Public Works employee who discovered Sarah’s body. She was floating inside the tank, face down. She was still wearing the same clothes she had on when she went missing from the police station. The day after they found her, I searched for information online. I wanted to know what happens to a body submerged in water for so long. I wanted to know what happened to Sarah after she died. To be honest, I don’t understand why I wanted to know, but I had to.
It turns out that a body lasts longer in water than it does on land. I assumed that the flesh would get all wet and soggy and that it’d all fall apart. However, according to this paper, cold water acts as a refrigerator, keeping the body fresh for longer. There are also different bacteria in the water, and they don’t consume the remains as fast. Then I saw the pictures on the gore websites. Dead corpses floating in rivers, on oceans. Wrinkled, putrefying lumps of human meat, meat that once held a soul. Then I saw a close-up of a body in the Ganges, a vulture plucking out its eyes. I shut my computer off and went to bed.
—
Detective Price Investigation Log, August 21st, 2010:
I’m now the head of an official “special investigation.” For the moment, the police of Catamount gotta do as I say. The local boys in blue can’t be happy about it, but fuck them. Their incompetence has killed three kids and has put a fourth life at risk. I saw the Moore girl’s body today. It was fucking awful. I’ve seen my share of dead bodies, but none as revolting as hers. I had never felt skin so wrinkly and desiccated nor such a revolting shade of orange-green.
The examiner concluded the obvious: death by drowning. The killer threw her into the water tower and left her to swim until she was too exhausted to swim anymore. The whole process leading to her death might’ve taken hours, even days. What a fucking horrible way to go. I have research materials coming up to Catamount tomorrow. Another detective pointed out the killings are lining up with ancient pagan holidays. Never thought I’d take out books from the Boston Public Library as part of a murder investigation. Theory: the killer thinks if he kills a few kids, the “Luck of the Irish” will be his.
Don’t cry because you got what you wanted, Price.
—
I pointed at the ornate dagger my Dad held and asked, “What’s that?”
My Dad turned around a little too fast. “This? It’s an old family heirloom.”
“I’ve never seen it before. What is it?”
My Dad put the knife back in the jewelry box he’d taken it out of and put the box back in the family safe. “It’s nothing. Don’t worry about it.”
Later that night, I got to examine the dagger up close. I had cracked the code to the family safe years ago (it was my Dad’s birthday). I waited until my parents were asleep, then crept downstairs and went to please my curiosity. The blade was extra-sharp for what my Dad described as a “family heirloom.” Sharp enough that he must’ve taken care of it recently. But the handle was far more fucked up than the blade itself. It was of high-quality lacquered wood.
There were four stick figures engraved on it, each of them marked differently:
– the first had a line cut through it.
– the second had a line wrapped around its neck, connected to a horizontal line above.
– a box with waves surrounding the third.
– fire surrounded the fourth.
—
Excerpt from “The Secret Inscriptions of the Oak-Seer”:
Soon, there will come a day when I will no longer be among you. On the day of my burial – which you must delay until the next holiday gathering – begins the great Ritual. The four Druids I will choose among you to become Noble Prophets will carry the burden. Their sacrifice will end our return to human bodies and give us entry to the Other World. Each of them must produce only one offspring. When the Ritual of Transmigration comes to pass, they will sacrifice the child. This will sever our connection to the mortal world.
Choose the order of sacrifices by a lot. Each death must fall on one of our Four Great Days as they follow my death.
Let the first child suffer impalement in the name of Andraste, Goddess of Victory.
Let the second child suffer flogging and hanging in the name of Esus, God of Vegetation.
Let the third child suffer drowning in the name of Toutatis, God of Protection.
Let the fourth child suffer immolation in the name of Taranis, God of Thunder.
Once you have given up these four Supreme Offerings, the Other-world is yours.
—
I couldn’t believe what I was reading. I even re-read the passage, hoping against hope that I read it wrong. But I hadn’t. It all made sense now. I flipped through the book again, trying to understand more. The following section mocked modern people for “denying the Old Gods their due.” Next was the section on the Wheel of Seasons, the “Four Great Days” of the cult’s year. The last one left was Samhain, the night of October 31st.’
Shit, that’s tomorrow. I have to get out of this town now. I grabbed the knife and the cult’s books and threw them in my bookbag. I’m shocked my parents weren’t woken up by all the noise I was making. I shut the safe and grabbed my jacket. I was about to run outside to the police, watching our home, but they weren’t there anymore. There was an unmarked black car, which was suspicious as fuck.
I slipped into our backyard instead and hid behind a tree growing in the corner. I took out my phone, took a deep breath, and called the only person I thought would help me.
“Detective Price here. Speak.”
—
Detective Price Investigation Log, October 30th, 2010:
Can’t believe the asshole Butler kid cracked the case while I was fucking asleep. That’s what I get for going to bed early. The kid calls me up a quarter past 11, babbling into the phone about how his parents will kill him. It took me five minutes of babysitting him over the phone to calm him down. Then he tells me he has proof: a ritual dagger and some notebooks filled with some wizard shit.
I told him to meet me at 7 11 near the police station and to show them to me. James looked shaken up when I met him. I could tell he wasn’t pulling a fast one on me immediately. The stuff he gave me would be damning everywhere but a murder trial. Their lawyer would argue it’s circumstantial and that we’re curbing religious freedom. However, circumstantial evidence is a good start compared to what the local police have found. I’m going to bring the parents in for questioning tomorrow. I can’t trust the local police anymore, so I’ll need to call in more boys from the Athol barracks. Both to back me up and to search for the officer who had ordered me to guard the Butler house. He’s still missing.
—
I’ve spent most of Halloween in this ratty, old motel room on the edge of town. A state police officer sits inside the room, and another is outside by the door. They aren’t talkative, and neither am I. Instead, I sit here and watch the news. My hometown has made national news for the first and only time in its history. The cops brought my parents in for questioning. Somebody tipped off the media, so all these journalists were there even though it was dawn. My parents said nothing while the state troopers escorting them cleared a path.
Detective Price held a press conference later that morning. All the local channels interrupted their broadcasts to air it. He quickly emphasized that neither of my parents was under arrest, but he called them “persons of interest.” I guess that’s what you call a suspect who you don’t want to lawyer up yet. He also made clear he had more “persons of interest”; he was “reaching out to” them that day. I assume he means the other Selectmen / Noble Prophets. Good, I hope they all suffer for what they’ve done.
—
YYou are now chatting with Christopher Moore. Say hi!
John Butler
They’re onto us. My son found the ritual items.
Christopher Moore
Are you still at the station?
John Butler
She got sent home. Jen’s still answering questions, but I’m scared she won’t be out in time for Samhain.
Christopher Moore
Our friends on the force will free her if necessary. Are you ready to present your offering?
John Butler
Of course, we are. But they have our son under guard somewhere.
Christopher Moore
Officer Adams said he was at the Econ-Lodge on Route 2. He will collect James.
John Butler
Soon, this will all be over. It’ll all be worth it.
—
Around sundown, there was a knock on the motel room door. Nobody had come by the room that day, not even housekeeping. The cop sitting next to me got up and opened the door. It was Officer Adams – the piece of shit himself – on the other side of the door. He smiled his smug grin and said to the state trooper, “Hey there, I’m here to take the kid back to the station. Price has more questions for him.”
The state trooper remained unconvinced. “Price told us to trust the kid with nobody but him.”
Adams kept on smiling while he replied, “He’s away. We found something in the woods near Mount Pocumtuck. He sent me, instead.”
The trooper shook his head, “I’ll have to clear it with Price first. Let me call him.”
As the trooper turned around and pulled out his cell phone, Officer Adams took out his gun and shot him in the back. He then turned and pumped two rounds into the head of the trooper standing outside. Both men were dead before they hit the floor. I stood up to run to the bathroom, but Officer Adams pressed his gun’s barrel into my forehead until I sat back down. He finally stopped smiling as he pointed to the door and said, “You’re coming with me.”
—
Detective Price Investigation Log, October 31st, 2010:
The parents didn’t crack once under questioning. They claimed James must’ve made the knife and books himself to frame them for “attention.” The two of them were cold as ice. I’ve never seen two “average” people so unfazed by an interrogation. There’s no doubt in my mind now that they’re involved. I guess James and his cult stuff was right on the money. But I need more evidence before I start making arrests.
Who else knows about this plan? Is every adult in Catamount part of it? If so, this investigation could become one of the biggest busts in state history. The only other event on this level would be the Innsmouth Raid of 1928. I must be careful with the moment because I’m in enemy territory. Somebody working at the Mount Pocumtuck Resort found a ritual sacrifice site. I’m taking some troopers with me. If I’m lucky, I’ll catch some of these freaks in the act of sacrifice. The Butler boy should be safe; the men guarding him have impeccable service records. This Halloween ought to be a quiet one for him.
—
“Where the fuck are you taking me?” I kicked at the mesh screen, dividing Officer Adam’s cruiser’s front and back seats. “Let me out, you asshole.”
Officer Adams laughed while turning his head to look at me. “Come on, James, I’m taking you to see your parents. They’re throwing a party for you.”
I almost asked for a second time when he was taking me, but then we passed by the sign for Mount Pocumtuck. I steadied myself; I couldn’t afford to panic yet. My eyes scanned the car, settling on the mesh screen. My last kick had knocked it loose. One more kick from me pushed it right into the back of his head. “What the fuck are you doing?” shrieked Adams while he pulled his service handgun out of its holster.
He turned again to look at me, taking his eyes off the road. Neither of us saw the stag standing in the middle of the road until it was too late. The impact sent the car off-road, down the mountain’s side, until it came to rest against a large boulder. I was already unconscious by this point, my forehead bleeding from a cut caused by flying glass. My sight went black, and I felt like I was dead.
—
Body From Burnt Car on Mount Pocumtuck ID’d
by Lisette Clark, Associated Press
December 4th, 2010
The Massachusetts State Police confirmed what many feared yesterday. The remains found in the burned car are Detective Christopher Price. Price, 39, was head of the investigation into the murders, now called the Catamount Cult Case. He had gone missing Halloween night while investigating a possible crime scene. It is still unknown how much of a role Price played in what’s now called the Pocumtuck Halloween Massacre.
That led to the deaths of twelve cult members, along with two state policemen. The identification of the remaining bodies found at Mount Pocumtuck Resort continues. In other Catamount news, Attorney General Martha Coakley announced ten new indictments. This brings the total number of people charged in the murders to almost 200. The state legislature plans to vote on dissolving the township in a special Monday vote.
—
I woke up about an hour after the crash. Officer Adams was dead, with a chunk of deer antler impaled through his face. I remember the feeling of relief that ran through me when I saw that asshole was killed. I grabbed his gun – it was lying on the front passenger seat – then crawled out of the car. I couldn’t walk far; the crash had injured my leg. So I sat behind the rock, trying to use the vehicle to hide. Once secure in my spot, I looked around to figure out where I was. That’s when I saw the stag we hit. It wasn’t dead, far from it. It was missing half of its left antler and had several deep gashes along its body. But it was alive and alert.
I looked into its eyes, and it looked back at me. It walked over to me, limping on its front left leg, which looked broken. The deer stood over me, its nostrils flaring as it sniffed me up and down. Then it laid down next to me, its healthy right antler touching my side. After much hesitation, I reached out and started petting it. Why? I don’t know, but it didn’t resist me or flee. It stayed with me until help arrived, after which it limped away.
—
NEWSCASTER: We will take you to Angela Adams at Mount Pocumtuck. Angela?
ANGELA ADAMS: Thank you, Bob. As you can see behind me, scattered fires litter the area even after hours of work by firefighters. What was once one of Massachusetts’ most popular resorts is now a smoldering ruin.
NEWSCASTER: Any word yet on survivors?
ANGELA ADAMS: The state police have confirmed that most of the resort’s night staff are alive and well. The cult took them hostage when police first arrived, but they escaped. Currently, police believe all members of the cult at the resort died in the fire they set.
NEWSCASTER: Any other updates?
ANGELA ADAMS: Yes. First, I can now confirm that Officer Britney Torres has died. That brings the number of cops killed in two separate incidents in Catamount last night to four. Finally, James Butler is at Bay State Franklin Medical Center and is in stable condition.
—
It took me months to find out how my parents died. I didn’t learn the whole story until the trials began. Even after all the plea bargains, I still had to testify several times. So many defendants had to use all the state courthouses west of Boston. It was all a huge mess. The cult beheaded them. It was my parent’s punishment for failing to offer me as a sacrifice. The surviving cultists testified to their belief that decapitation destroyed the soul. So not only were my parents denied the “Other-world,” they had no afterlife at all.
I didn’t react at all when I heard what happened to them. My parents are nothing to me now—no love for the people who created me, knowing what was in store. I don’t hate them, either, since I’m sure they felt justified by their faith. There’s no use in holding onto your hate of people who are dead. Their bodies are now a pile of ash and bones in some police evidence bag. The state asked if I wanted their remains returned after the trial. I want nothing more to do with them.
—
Catamount Becoming a State Forest
by Dora Garcia, Associated Press
March 19th, 2012
Catamount, Massachusetts, once home to a notorious cult, will soon be gone forever. Governor Deval Patrick announced the plans at a press conference yesterday. The state plans to use eminent domain to buy the remaining private property. Once the remaining residents move out, their houses will get torn down. The plan comes after a recent spate of arson in the area raised fears that organized crime may be moving in. Once the remaining structures come down, the site will become a state forest.
For those still living in the area – many life-long residents of Catamount – the news is bittersweet. Memories of the town as it once was are tempered with the knowledge that Catamount is infamous. The city is now associated with the Oak-Seers. This cult ran the town and carried out many human sacrifices. The cult was a local secret until murders in 2010 brought the group to light.
—
I visited Catamount today, the first time I had been there since Halloween night a decade ago. Since his parents adopted me, Karim has been my legal brother, and he came with me. Of course, there is no Town of Catamount anymore, only Catamount State Forest. There’s not much more forest there now than when I left. When the state seized the land, the plan was to tear the buildings down. But then, the construction firm hired to oversee the project collapsed.
So, I spent the day walking through an artificial forest of dilapidated houses. We tried to navigate our way around ripped-up roads and downed power lines. My old home was one of the ones burned down by the serial arsonist, but we found Karim’s old house. We took a bunch of photos to post on Instagram. Graffiti covered the walls, much of it Satanic in nature. 16-year-old me would think the artwork was incredible; some was well done. 26-year-old me found it tasteless, but Karim found it all hilarious; “can’t even get the cult right.”
—
Top 10 Most Haunted Ghost Towns in America
– 10: Catamount, Massachusetts
Starting off our list is America’s newest ghost town, but one with the creepiest backstory. You know about Catamount and the cult that ran it like a suburban Illuminati. If not, check out this episode of the “Conspiracies You Can Believe In” podcast that covers the topic. As for being haunted, this place has weird goings-on in spades. The site is located near Vermont’s Bennington Triangle. Some paranormal experts believe this fuels the supernatural in this state forest.
There are both eyewitness reports and videos of strange lights atop Mount Pocumtuck. These lights vanish when approached. Photographs showing shadow people near the site of the murders went viral in 2018. These still get featured spots on amateur YouTube “Scariest Ghost Sightings” videos. But do beware of the hooded cultists that local teens claim to see in the abandoned houses. They might invite you to their next sacrifice.
—
“Hey, mister, you see any hooded dudes hanging out?”
I turned around so fast that I stumbled over the desk beside me. I assumed I was the only person on the second floor of the high school. It serves me right to trust Karim to keep watch. My fear of getting beaten up dissipated once I laid eyes on the thin boy standing at the other end of the classroom.
I answered, “You know that’s an urban legend, right? The police arrested everyone in the cult.”
The kid scoffed before replying, “Did you see that Kay-cast with the 3AM challenge in Catamount? He got chased out by a cultist!”
I laughed, “Do you believe everything you see on YouTube?”
The kid was getting indignant. “Kay cast is raw shit. I even subscribe to his Patreon.”
I didn’t want to further upset the kid, so I shrugged my shoulders and walked towards him. “What are you doing here, anyway, stranger?”
“My name’s Simon, and I’m here to get ghost videos for YouTube.”
—
Excerpt from “The Secret Inscriptions of the Oak-Seer”:
There may come a time when the outside world discovers our secret shared virtue. America may try to destroy us like the Romans wanted to kill us in our past lives when we ruled our ancestors. They failed to beat us when we practiced in the open, and their heirs will fail to destroy our secret society. Should all our preparations fail, do not be afraid. Scatter to the four winds, like seeds eruption from a dandelion in bloom. Catamount – our Hy-Brazil, our sacred mount – will call you back when the time is right.
The town may die, but the vertices of magic that drew us here at the start of the 20th century will remain forever. Gather here under cover of night, with practitioners old and new. Consecrate this holy mountain again with worthy sacrifices. Even those ignorant of all magic will come to this area when it calls to them. Seize those you deem worthy, and slay them, body and soul. The quintessence released by the Ritual will empower you, and the Gods will protect you.
—
Karim and I were standing with our new friend Simon outside what was once the police station. I asked him, “You sure you don’t want a ride back to town? This place isn’t too safe at night.”
Simon shook his head, “I’ll be safe. Two friends of mine are driving up from Greenfield. They’ll be here before nightfall. They’re both big football players.”
Now it was Karim’s turn to shake his head. “Alright, if you insist on doing this 3AM Challenge, have fun. Tell any ghosts you meet I said ‘hi.’”
Simon was already walking away from us, trying to find a signal with his phone. “Will do, mister.”
Karim laughed to himself as we walked through the deserted streets. “Think we should’ve told him we knew those ghosts when they were still alive?”
“What, and get dragged into hanging out in these woods overnight?”
“Yeah, you’re right. Simon’s a good kid, but he got on my nerves after an hour.”
I stopped walking and turned back to look at the town center one last time. “I hope Simon knows this a bad place for a kid his age to be.”
—
Search Continues for Missing Local Teen
by Tobias Myers, Associated Press
July 22nd, 2019
Park rangers continue to search Catamount State Forest for Simon Edwards, 17. Myers, a resident of Greenfield, went missing one week ago. He was last seen by two other men, former residents of Catamount, who met him while exploring the area. Police consider neither man a suspect in the disappearance. Simon was in the area to film a “3AM Challenge” video for his YouTube channel. This genre involves people staying overnight in “haunted” locations. Simon had gone out alone to scout filming locations in the infamous abandoned town.
His friends, Robert Moses and Cyril Martinez, arrived later that night. When they couldn’t find Simon, they called the local police to report him missing. A spokeswoman for the state police confirmed that law enforcement suspects no foul play and that the police believe Simon is still alive. Some cops—who asked to remain anonymous—speculated this may be a stunt by the boy. Simon often spoke of the urban legend of a murderous cult hiding in the state forest.